Separation and Parenting Arrangements Dispute in Bundoora

Family Law

31/07/2026

The Situation – Separation and dispute over parenting arrangements

A father of four sought to achieve a 50/50 care arrangement for his children following separation. Both parents were loving, capable, and actively involved in the children’s lives. Each parent worked full-time, and there was no genuine dispute that both were able to provide appropriate care.

Initially, the mother had agreed to an equal shared care parenting arrangement. However, after engaging legal representation, her position changed. She opposed the father having 50% care and instead proposed that he have only approximately 30% care of the children.

The matter then became unnecessarily adversarial. Correspondence from the other party’s lawyers included unfounded personal criticisms of the father and repeated letters that appeared to prolong the dispute without proper justification. This increased pressure on the father and had the potential to significantly increase legal costs.

The key challenges were:

  • protecting the father’s relationship with his children;
  • demonstrating that equal care was in the children’s best interests;
  • responding to unfounded allegations without allowing the matter to become unnecessarily inflamed;
  • keeping legal costs proportionate and predictable; and
  • ensuring the father remained financially able to re-establish himself and provide a stable home for the children.

What Hitchens Legal Did to Help

Hitchens Legal worked closely with the father to maintain a clear, evidence-based strategy focused on the best interests of the children.

Rather than being distracted by personal attacks or unnecessary correspondence, Hitchens Legal consistently redirected the matter back to the relevant legal issues, including:

  • the children’s existing relationship with both parents;
  • the father’s historical involvement in their care;
  • each parent’s capacity to meet the children’s needs;
  • the practicality of an equal care arrangement;
  • the importance of stability, routine, and meaningful time with both parents; and
  • the absence of any valid reason why the father’s time should be limited to 30%.

Hitchens Legal pushed back firmly against the mother’s changed position and the allegations being raised, relying on evidence to demonstrate that equal care was appropriate and in the children’s best interests.

Cost certainty was also a significant part of the support provided. The father was primarily assisted on a fixed-fee basis, with cost estimates provided upfront where relevant. This meant he was not taken by surprise by legal fees and was able to make informed decisions throughout the matter.

Outcome

Ultimately, the mother accepted that it was in the children’s best interests for the father to have equal care.

The Court agreed and made orders providing for the father to have 50% care of the children.

The father achieved the parenting arrangement he had sought from the outset. Importantly, because his legal costs were managed through fixed fees and clear cost estimates, he was able to preserve a greater portion of his financial resources.

As a result of the cost-effective approach taken, together with the proceeds of sale from the former matrimonial home and the agreed financial settlement, the father was also able to put a deposit on a new home. This allowed him to establish a stable and suitable home environment for himself and his children.

How the Client Felt at the End

At the conclusion of the matter, the father was extremely happy and grateful for the assistance provided by Hitchens Legal.

He felt heard, supported, and protected throughout a difficult and emotionally charged process. He was particularly relieved that:

  • he obtained the 50/50 care arrangement he had sought from the beginning;
  • the Court recognised that equal care was in the children’s best interests;
  • he avoided being financially overwhelmed by unpredictable legal costs; and
  • he was able to purchase a home and create a secure environment for his children.

The outcome gave the father both parenting certainty and financial stability, enabling him to move forward with confidence and focus on his children’s wellbeing.

Scroll to Top